My First Time is an off-Broadway play that opened on July 12, 2007 at New World Stages and ran until January 22, 2010. The show is based on a website that grew in popularity in 1998 "that allowed people to anonymously share their own true stories about their First Times" (http://www.myfirsttime.com/) and "features four actors in hysterical and heartbreaking stories about first sexual experiences written by real people ...